Contingent Fee Business Litigation Blog
Houston: Not Yet the Next Marshall
Patent infringement suit filings have remained relatively steady for the past eight years, according to Stanford Law School’s Intellectual Property Clearinghouse. New patent suits range between 2,300 and 2,800 filings per year. But Marshall, Texas is the venue of choice for a disproportionally high number of those filings. Since January 1, 2008, for example, there have been 295 patent suits filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas. And sixty percent of the district’s patent suits are traditionally filed in the district’s Marshall Division.
There are several reasons why plaintiffs’ lawyers prefer Marshall. The sitting judges and their magistrates are considered fair and experienced. Jurors in the division have also demonstrated a deep respect for individual property rights. And there is a perception, although no longer substantiated, that cases reach trial quickly through Marshall’s “rocket docket.”
But another reason why plaintiffs prefer Marshall is the district’s “Rules of Practice for Patent Cases.” Those rules require prompt disclosure of discoverable information and prevent gamesmanship in the discovery process. More importantly, the rules are strictly enforced by the judges and magistrates. Plaintiffs’ lawyers know that they will be able to get the information necessary to support their case; and get it quickly or have an available remedy.
The crush of patent cases filed in Marshall over several years has caused its “rocket docket” to slow. And plaintiffs may search for other venues. One possibility is the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas (located primarily in Houston, Texas). The venue may become attractive because, effective January 1, 2008, the district adopted its own “Rules of Practice for Patent Cases” that mirror those used in Marshall. Adoption of those rules, however, has not yet lead to a dramatic increase in patent suit filings. Only thirty-two patent cases have been filed in the district during 2008 (compared to twenty-eight last year). Time will tell whether the new rules attract suit filings. Because new suits filed under those rules are just now becoming ripe for the adjudication of discovery disputes, we will soon learn whether judges and magistrates in the Southern District of Texas apply the rules as strictly as the jurists in Marshall. If so, plaintiffs’ lawyers may find Houston a more attractive venue for their patent cases.
mcclanahan ● myers ● espey, llp
3355 West Alabama | Suite 210 | Houston, Texas 77098 | Phone: (713) 223-2005